Love Quinn, an unhealthy type of ENFJ personality type, does not belong in this category. antisocial disorder, being a narcissist, and co-dependency issues. And the only reason she was able to do these thingswithout being disturbed by the public was because Love had the funds to open the bakery alone. INFJs frequently become overwhelmed by other peoples emotions, lose their own identities, and seek out ways to please others. Not so fast. As a psychologist, what would be your diagnosis of Joe Goldberg - Quora Retrieved from netflix/watch/80212201?trackId=13752289. Love craves violence and chaos, and that was very clear in Season 3. Love, however, didnt give a single shit about that. On the outside, a cooling-down period may appear to be a peaceful process, but on the inside, the victim is constantly trying to figure out how to get over the narcissist. After being in Because Joe is a charming character, most people watching the show find themselves rooting for him, even when he is facing the well deserved consequences of his own actions. In Season 3 at least, one could argue that Joe killed for purpose (offing Ryan to give Marienne custody of her child and poisoning Love to free himself and Henry), while Love was impulsive and let jealousy and anger control her decisions. Joe had a nightmarish childhood. However, at different times Joe also demonstrates behavior consistent with the rejected stalker, the resentful stalker, and the predatory stalker (although he's never the incompetent stalker). moments, they both are similar is stating things come from when we are younger and explains He cant be in love with anything, no matter how much he is addicted or obsessed with it. And you're more able to control them and possess them.". The memes (oh, the memes *spoiler warning*) about You currently littering the internet all seem to have one thing in common: They support main character Joe Goldberg despite his manipulative, violent, and downright psychopathic behavior. 'You's' Penn Badgley Says Fans Can't Be Entirely Blamed for Liking Joe He is incapable of being in love with anyone. The Role of Trauma in Netflix Series 'You' Season 3 He has a mindset of telling his victims that he is only there to help them, he Joe will do whatever in his means to help them out in This is based on his manipulative and often violent behavior towards others, which appears to be motivated by a desire for power and control. The fact that he has no remorse about killing any of them just shows that he could honestly even kill Paco if he somehow becomes a threat to Joe. Growing up, Joe became parentless when his mother abandoned him, and he grew up in a group home where he was profoundly mistreated by the other boys in the house. "You can do it in a non-physical way. Although he seems like a nice guy there is something off about him; he has various personality traits where it seems like he is more than one person. People who engage in stalking behaviors can suffer from many issues, such as personality disorders like narcissistic personality disorder, delusional disorder, or attachment disorders. While Joe Goldberg is an extreme type of psychopath, we can't guarantee milder versions won't enter your life. Lynzee Smith What Is Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD)? It can also be seen that Joes fear of abandonment leads him to possess anyone he becomes infatuated with out of a fear of unreciprocated feelings. Joe does not know his biological mother, Sandy, and he And its pretty iconic. He always seems to mirror others, is dishonest, and completely selfish when it comes to his own child. The murders of Joe and Love differ in several ways, as do the types of serial killers. Often narcissists fly under the radar because they use their charm and wit to seem normal and unsuspecting. How Accurate is The Depiction of Stalking in Netflix's You? - Verywell Mind Joe's fear of rejection and dissociation from his body (as manifested by compulsive masturbation, premature ejaculation, and impotence) are characteristic of borderline personality disorder. His upbringing is influenced by strong morals, idealistic beliefs, and a desire to lead a better life. The type of person who follows their own cases in the media, as well as who may contact or cause problems with investigators. Am J Psychiatry. He is a great example of how someone can be diagnosed using psychoanalysis. 8 True Crime Shows To Stream After American Murder: The Family Next Door, 12 Oct 2020 All of these traits fit the criteria for someone with psychopathy. "[In season 3]," Hatters Friedman says, "he's trying hard to do the right thing and to be a good dad, which implies some ability to attach to others and to have empathy for the child.". Lets get to the bottom of it, shall we? In the end, no matter how much he loves someone, it seems like he will always choose to save himself no matter what. Although his morals are clearly flawed, Joe Goldberg sticks to them relentlessly. He hurt his loved ones and others whom he suspected. Joe is very narcissistic and has a grandiose sense of self. Fact checkers review articles for factual accuracy, relevance, and timeliness. Goldberg's penchant for harming or killing those close to his love interest and obsession Beck also suggest he's morbidly codependent, according to Rutledge. What kind of mental illness does Joe Goldberg, the main character of Season 2 of "You" gets deeper into Goldberg's past and uncovers clues that suggest he actually has an attachment disorder, according to Scott. INFJ is a combination of the three functions (introverted feeling, moderately developed sense-making, and judging abilities). They can empathize with peoples problems and understand their emotions. The first and second seasons' plots revolve around the seemingly normal life of . :P) but another reader likely wouldn't have. Joe is a pervert who doesnt have self control even a bit. 40 Comments Please sign inor registerto post comments. definition has now broadened to include anyone who was "wounded" as a child, the so-called Both narcissistic and borderline individuals usually experience chronic instability in their personal Continue Reading 36 Sponsored by PureCare Knee Protector The release reignited Twitter speculations about Goldberg's mental health that have been swirling since season 1. Even when something goes awry, "if we already had this preconceived notion that this person is sensitive and emotionally present, it's very easy for us to believe they're a good person.". Copyright 2023 StudeerSnel B.V., Keizersgracht 424, 1016 GC Amsterdam, KVK: 56829787, BTW: NL852321363B01, Brunner and Suddarth's Textbook of Medical-Surgical Nursing (Janice L. Hinkle; Kerry H. Cheever), Civilization and its Discontents (Sigmund Freud), Business Law: Text and Cases (Kenneth W. Clarkson; Roger LeRoy Miller; Frank B. Most of the mans crimes were committed out of pure impulse and he does not formulate entire plans to murder or kidnap people; instead, rage and panic are what drive him to do the things he does in the moment. Now dont get me wrong, both Joe and Love are murderers and psychopaths. Everyone has a darkness and a light inside them. Although he knows better than to project his intentions to hurt or kill, he lures or sneaks up on his victims in order to more easily enact his brutal plans. locked in a glass cage and torture him. In some ways, Goldberg embodies both conditions because he's constantly violent when he believes a person has wronged him, a common justification people with both illnesses make for their behavior. Joe Goldberg is the main character of You, the extremely popular TV series based on a series of novels by Caroline Kepnes. A relationship that is abusive or harmful does not have to be physically violent. "If you're vulnerable because you're looking for someone to rescue you," Neo adds, "then sophisticated psychopaths and dark personality types are going to be out for you. Originally posted by omisteriodasduasirmas. Joes goal in life is to torture and kill, and he enjoys doing so. stressful situations due to how he grew up. Delilah Alves. Fredrick, C. (2020, August 17). Its worth paying close attention to what Joes sign indicates about his personality in either case. Mental Health Specialist & Coach - Author - Bibliotherapist - Book Reviewer My name is Ashley Nestler, and I have my master's of social work with an emphasis in mental health, as well as certifications in mental health coaching, art therapy coaching, crystal healing, dialectical behavior therapy, and bibliotherapy. However, while this shift in dynamic started to finally mellow out Joe, it turned Love into even more of a psychopath. Cognitive behavioral therapist Dr. Avigail Lev, director of Bay Area CBT Center and founder of CBT Online, gets more specific, diagnosing Joe with covert malignant narcissism. There are people willing to assist you in your time of need. Personality (10th ed.). Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. "From a clinical perspective, the word 'psychopath' doesn't mean anything.". For example, when she murdered her nanny as a child, the Quinn family covered it up. The main couple in Season 3 has a very interesting connection. Hatters Friedman and Lev particularly cited Joe's behavior toward his newborn son in the third season of the series as unrealistic. And no matter what he's doing to win the heart of his latest obsession, including theft and murder, he sees all of his behavior as justified because it is done to help her and their relationship. In fact, both Hatters Friedman and Lev point out that even though Joe may seem like he truly loves Beck, Love, or the other women he obsesses over, the show subtly demonstrates that, like a real-life malignant narcissist, he doesn't see these characters as human beings with strengths and weaknesses of their own. Pastoral Psychology, 50 (1), 3952. So let You serve as a guidebook on what not to do in a new relationship. Joe Goldberg is one of those rare sociopaths who come across as very charming. Trust your intuition, watch for the red flags, and, for God's sake, buy some curtains. It can come out in parenting and using your child to meet your own needs in a way that is massively detrimental to your child's needs," like Goldberg's mother is seen doing in flashbacks during season 2. You've done a fantastic job of describing each of the defense mechanisms. COMPARISON OF THEORISTS: Joe Goldberg What redeeming qualities does Goldberg have that other superheroes dont have? Just as you are responsible for your own issues and your own demons, someone else is responsible for theirs [] Relationships fundamentally are about interdependence rather than dependence.". No need to be fancy, just an overview. The initial tag of being a psychopath, though not wrong, doesnt tell the complete story. him the value of books and reading. And as it so happens, we can learn a lot from Joe Goldberg. While individuals who seem excessively self-absorbed or have an inflated sense of self-importance are often referred to as narcissists, those with narcissistic traits don't necessarily qualify for the diagnosis of narcissistic personality disorder. As part of this process, the individual is first idealized, then devalued, re-examined, and eventually discarded when no longer necessary. THE PSYCHOANALYSIS OF JOE GOLDBERG | Netflix Series You | Perspectives from a Christian Therapist 388 views Sep 16, 2020 25 Dislike Share Wholistic Healing 481 subscribers In this video I am. Unlike Joe and Love, both serial killers are typically narcissistic, whereas Joe is a textbook example ofYandere, whereas Love is a typical, garden-variety killer. Medical/Surgical Nursing Concepts (NUR242), Nursing B43 Nursing Care of the Medical Surgical (NURS B43), Introduction To Project Management Software (CSBU539), Professional Application in Service Learning I (LDR-461), Advanced Anatomy & Physiology for Health Professions (NUR 4904), Principles Of Environmental Science (ENV 100), Operating Systems 2 (proctored course) (CS 3307), Comparative Programming Languages (CS 4402), Business Core Capstone: An Integrated Application (D083), Amelia Sung - Guided Reflection Questions, 1010 - Summary Worlds Together Worlds Apart, Chapter 1 - Principles of Animal Behavior, 3.4.1.7 Lab - Research a Hardware Upgrade, Chapter 1 - BANA 2081 - Lecture notes 1,2, TB-Chapter 21 Peripheral Vascular System and Lymphatic System, Tina Jones Heent Interview Completed Shadow Health 1, Chapter 1 - Summary Give Me Liberty! Goldberg shows signs of antisocial personality disorder. No, the main character from 'You' isn't romantic - NME Studies have shown a clear link between the development of post-traumatic stress disorder and personality disorders, particularly that of antisocial personality disorder, which is often the result of trauma in adolescence as well as negative or broken attachments. There are three types of killers: organized killers, medical killers, and disorganized killers. he is a sociopath and is obsessed with Beck, he continually stalks her and gets rid of anyone who will distance her from Joe. : an American History (Eric Foner), The Methodology of the Social Sciences (Max Weber), PSY 255 Trait Theory Short Answer Worksheet, Introduction to Personality Media Analysis Worksheet, Persuasive Essay-Thesis Statement and Gathering Resources Worksheet. That's why later in life Goldberg becomes obsessively attached to women he believes can give him what he needs and is motivated to get the love, or idea of love, he craves by any means necessary while still showing glimpses of empathy. Love and connection are primary factors that we often seek, and they are Joes primary motivation as well. As we see in season 2 and season 3, his troubled childhood and the fact that he was abandoned by his mother seemingly gave Joe severe codependency issues. Joe is a narcissist who desperately seeks to fill his emptiness because he craves supply. So far, two seasons have been released, and the highly anticipated third season is coming out this October. become as dangerous as murdering to help these women out. Visit Insider's homepage for more. We can see now that Joe Goldberg suffers from multiple different things, such as After finding out that he is having a son, rather than a daughter like he had hoped, Joe becomes distraught. style is a defense mechanism intended to ward off feelings of anxiety". You can reach out to the National Domestic Violence Hotline by calling victimconnect.org or the hotline.org. Naturally, one would be charmed by Joe Goldberg. This is an accurate example of how psychopaths gaslight others. Note that I wanted you to describe the conflict in the unconscious for each of the 5, but you have done this well in the first couple. They can act in self-defense to save himself and his mother from his father. Retrieved on September 21, 2020 YOU [Video He has often been described as a psychopath, but opinions have differed on what exactly ails our hero. Joe Goldberg Personality Type, Zodiac Sign & Enneagram Cognitive behavioral therapist Dr. Avigail Lev, director of Bay Area CBT Center and founder of CBT Online, gets more specific, diagnosing Joe with covert malignant narcissism. She relied heavily on Joe this season to clean up her murders and craft stories to ensure that the killings never pointed back to her. Since he is a fictional character, the more we find out about him in subsequent seasons, the more accurate a diagnosis of his mental state can be made. This ad is displayed using third party content and we do not control its accessibility features. Conclusion Cynthia Vinney, PhD is an expert in media psychology and a published scholar whose work has been published in peer-reviewed psychology journals. ", They're masters of making "the right first impressions, creating this perception, weaving this little web in which they learn about you and stage their entrance into your life," says Neo. Books, and horror, especially, have helped me a lot through my struggles with my mental health, and I enjoy sharing the healing power of books with others. Joe Goldberg is one of those rare sociopaths who come across as very charming. Anushka Sens Am I Next To Release Digitally This Womens Day, Actress Says Im Fortunate To Be A Part Of Such An Important Film, Farzi: Prime Video Curates A One-Of-A-Kind Show-Themed Perfume That Smells Of Freshly Minted Notes. Leiden, Luke. With both Freud and Jung dealing with earlier life and And above all that, when Joe was civil and asked for a divorce like a normal person, Love decided to paralyse him with poison so he could watch her kill Marienne to save their family. Date: September 22, 2020, Comparison of Theorists: Joe Goldberg Impulsive decision-making, antisocial behavior, and/or little to no guilt and empathy are just a few other traits aside from superficial harm found in psychopaths, which can clearly be seen in Joe. He is also very manipulative and has a lack of empathy. He is a master in the skill of manipulating people using his innocent face. If the whole show gave you a bad case of the creeps, Neo offered some additional advice. Joe Goldberg has established specific coping methods when it comes to functioning in high What Does It Really Mean To Be An Extrovert. At the same time, more information offered in "You" season 2 suggests Goldberg may not have antisocial personality disorder, but an attachment disorder related to childhood trauma. However, it is so much more than that. Joe Goldberg When it comes to the most intelligent characters on You, Joe Goldberg would have to be named number one. Antisocial personality disorder, or psychopathy, is a mental disorder that Joe Goldberg quite evidently struggles with. These individuals often have a poor understanding of dating rituals as well as a sense of entitlement to a relationship. Of course, Joe is fictional and You is entertainment, so the TV show's portrayal of the character, and the hope that's built into the story could be seen as taking the romance narrative trope of the man seeking redemption through love to the extreme, Furthermore, Hatters Friedman notes that You and some fans' attraction to Joe could be seen as the continuation of a trend thats long been part of popular culture. I am the author of three novels, and my poems and short stories have been published in various anthologies. His issues also seem to stem a lot from his childhood experiences, which make him obsessively codependent on his partner (or someone he envisions as being his partner), and when things dont work out, the antisocial (ASPD) tendencies kick in. I utilize my eclectic variety of skills to inform my mental health practice and provide my clients with the best skills to be able to manage their mental health. Some people who have been diagnosed with antisocial personality Klestzick, Rebecca. The 33-year-old actor's comment was made in response to Colbert asking him: "Do you have anything to say to the people out there that say they want to date Joe, despite the minor flaw of murdering people?" "It's not a clinical portrayal of a serial killer," Badgley said after defending fans. Despite Love thinking that she was killing to protect her marriage and family, she was just needlessly killing with no restraint. It is possible to modify the four steps of the original cycle of abuse in narcissistic relationships. When we look at Joe's history, we see that he was brought up in a horrible, mistreated If you've watched Netflix's You, there's a chance you may have started to second-guess yourself recently. He had the potential to be such a good person and the ability to use his great skill of reading people to do more good than bad, but he chose the dark road. gain that love back (Burger, 2019). Android & IOS users, download our mobile app for faster than ever Bollywood & Box Office updates! I can really see the thought you have put into this, and your analysis of the show is excellent. We all like to think we're great judges of character. In the end, Indeed, people with antisocial personality disorder are more inclined to break the law than those with narcissistic personality disorder, psychologist Stanton Samenow wrote on Psychology Today. Womens Day 2023: Agar Tum Saath Ho, Aarya, Aranyak, Maharani & Other Must-Binge OTT Series To Celebrate Womens Resilience & Strength! However, his charming demeanor keeps him under the radar even as his body count rises, and Joe Goldberg keeps falling in love again and again. Jung had similar views like Freud did. So let You serve as a guidebook on what not to do in a new relationship. One thing that could improve this submission is a short summary of the show and characters at the very beginning. This is something that's dismayed his portrayer Badgley and that Lev believes is dangerous because people with malignant narcissism won't improve even if they seek out treatment. Study of stalkers. Joe seems like a hopeless romantic One day he got fed up with his mother being abused, he killed his father in Plans out his murders, Just do has a cover story, & it is able to fully backtrack & cover everything up #YouNetflix #YOUSEASON3 pic.twitter.com/lXScPy2jHK. ", However, You's characterization of Joe Goldberg isn't flawless. Psychoanalysis of "You"'s Joe Goldberg - MW Ontario Joe Goldberg - other - COMPARISON OF THEORISTS 1 COMPARISON - StuDocu Narcissism varies in severity from person to person. things to understand who Joe is and where he came from, then we can get into analyzing who Freud stated, "adult defenses, are related to early childhood experiences" (Burger, 2019), making sense why he acts how he is The Perfect Villain That Romance Built: Joe Goldberg on "You" - Psycom Dr. Nicky applies psychoanalysis in one . And we try to do that for other people, especially if we are very understanding of other people. Joe Goldberg'S Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder in Caroline individuals' personal memories and ideas," which why Joe would defend the person he loved to Worrall, Daina. "adult child" (Whitfield, 1991, pg. Ever.". What is the status of Joe and his relationship with you? Cookies collect information about your preferences and your devices and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. Over time, the you Joe obsesses over changes but his belief in true loveand what he has to do to ensure it happensnever does. Strangership and Privilege in Netflix's You. UBC English Students' Association, 2 Feb. 2020, www.ubcenglish.com/why-does-everyone-like-joe-goldberg-strangership-and-privilege-in-netflixs-you/. To win over his ever-changing objects of desire, Joe also employs appalling means that are highly illegal. Strangership and Privilege in Netflix's You.. Netflixs You follows Joe Goldberg as he leaves a trail of dead bodies on his search for the perfect partner. As for antisocial behavior, Joe does not have any friends, nor does he make any effort to befriend others, aside from children who he feels obligated to care for. While working with Mr. Mooney as a teen, he adopted Joe. We know what he's doing is wrong, so why do we root for him? found a New York bookstore, Mooney's, as a manager. There, youll also find thoughts and questions by our community. Melisandre from Game of Thrones. Privacy As a result, it is clear that Joe Goldberg is likely to suffer from antisocial and narcissistic personality disorder. Joe's development of obsessions with different women often leads to violence due to his inability to create and maintain positive relationships, and he often resorts to violence when he feels as though he is being abandoned. household that has made him codependent as an adult. Joes development of obsessions with different women often leads to violence due to his inability to create and maintain positive relationships, and he often resorts to violence when he feels as though he is being abandoned. "A diagnosis is almost never clean-cut and disorders overlap. that-romance-built-joe-goldberg-on-you/. He is portrayed by Penn Badgley in his first villainous role. From an early age, Joe didnt learn how to develop a positive attachment style due to his abandonment and mistreatment, which led to the development of narcissism, antisocial personality disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder. The fact that Goldberg comes off as extremely charming from the first time viewers are introduced to him is another reason he could be a narcissist, something that ranges from the full-blown disorder to a personality trait. Stalkers who fall into the "intimacy-seeking group or even the incompetent group, they've watched rom-coms and TV shows [that suggest] 'this is how you get the girl,'" Hatters Friedman says, "and so [You's] a little bit about, too, what as society we tell people is appropriate suitor-type behavior.". His work at the CIA garnered three Exceptional Performance Awards. As Lev put it, "Hollywood wants the happy ending, and in reality, when women are in this relationship [with a malignant narcissist], they do not have a happy ending. Your email address will not be published. Do you want to share your story? Yet, while the third season may be the least successful at portraying Joe's pathology, there are hints of him feeling remorse and empathy in the first two seasons as well, especially in season 2 when he expresses a great deal of guilt about what he did to Beck at the end of season 1. "Joe [Goldberg] would be a good example of misdiagnosis," Scott said. Cross), Psychology (David G. Myers; C. Nathan DeWall), Forecasting, Time Series, and Regression (Richard T. O'Connell; Anne B. Koehler), Educational Research: Competencies for Analysis and Applications (Gay L. R.; Mills Geoffrey E.; Airasian Peter W.), Principles of Environmental Science (William P. Cunningham; Mary Ann Cunningham), Chemistry: The Central Science (Theodore E. Brown; H. Eugene H LeMay; Bruce E. Bursten; Catherine Murphy; Patrick Woodward), Campbell Biology (Jane B. Reece; Lisa A. Urry; Michael L. Cain; Steven A. Wasserman; Peter V. Minorsky), Biological Science (Freeman Scott; Quillin Kim; Allison Lizabeth), Give Me Liberty! He kills people because he believes that killing them is necessary to protect his loved ones and improve the world around him. Stalking is a good way to get there. boundaries and relationality. The Id is described as the "unconscious energy" that strives to satisfy basic sexual and aggressive drives. He fears that he wont be able to protect his son, Henry, from what he himself was subjected to as a child, and he struggles to form a connection with him. Rejected stalkers stalk their victims in response to the dissolution of a former relationship, most often a former partner but sometimes a parent or friend. Sign up for notifications from Insider! It is also possible that you will require professional assistance. 27-29)." Looking deeper into Antisocial Personality Disorder, In the latest season, we watched Joe and Love move to the picturesque town of Madre Linda to raise their son, Henry. Abnormal Psych Case Study.docx - Case Study of Joe Goldberg For example, when Beck ex-lover, Benji, whom she did not want in her life anymore. Gaslighting, verbal abuse, and intimidation are some of the most common forms of abusive behavior. Even though Joe, unsettlingly played by Penn Badgley, is fictional, his patterns of behavior toward the latest object of his desire come across as frighteningly realistic. Design: Cierra Miller/STYLECASTER. On December 26, Netflix released the highly-anticipated second season of its original thriller series "You," which centers around narrator Joe Goldberg, a young man who has a pattern of becoming obsessed with certain women, stalking them, winning them over, and killing anyone around them he believes has wronged his lover. Burger stated that "According to Karen Horney, children growing up in anxiety- As a result, you may have found yourself wondering how accurate the series' depiction of stalking is. Joe Goldberg Sophia LeGris Psychoanalytic Theory Freud's theory of personality is made up of 3 major unconscious motives and conflicts, but I would like to turn the focus to one; The Id. Then when Joe and Love invited Sherry and Cary over to have sex, Love went beserk when she noticed that Joe was simply fantasising about having sex with another woman.